When the documentary Blackfish came out in 2013 it hit the world by storm. Tilikum, “Tilly”, the killer whale of interest at SeaWorld, soon became a household name but for all the wrong reasons, namely for the fact that he was tied to three fatalities and could be attributed to the closing of an marine life enclosure. The film explored the relationship between killer whales in captivity and humans is highlighted and explored throughout the film, opening conversation to begin taking over how it is that we perceive animals lives to be lesser than ours and how that has lead to horrific accidents attributed to this beautiful, dangerous wildlife. Blackfish forces our eyes open to the unethical treatment of not only killer whales but all animals we decide to hold captive. Because it’s never just the animals we capture that are impacted. We must start thinking of the physical changes they go through due to capture, their relations with other captured animals, and how our patterns of selection are taking away from necessary ecosystems.
When Tilly was first captured in 1983, it was off the coast of Iceland. This event alone can be looked down upon simply for its procedure and lack of empathy. Tilly and two others were captured at the time in a purse-seine net-a vertically long net weighed down at the bottom and kept afloat on the top by buoys-and then separated, leaving Tilly to begin his decade long process of transferring between facilities. This is where Blackfish director Gabriela Cowperthwaite argues his aggression began.
After spending a year post-capture at the Hafnarfjördur Marine Zoo in Reykjavik, Iceland, Tilly was transferred to Sealand of the Pacific, located on Vancouver Island, Canada at a small city named Victoria. He was there for eight years constantly subjected to ill behavior by two older female killer whales (Haida II and Nootka IV) within the same enclosure. Being out of his natural habitat and under constant stress from these two orcas, Cowperthwaite pinpoints this as being where violent attitudes in killer whales can be traced back to. It is unsurprising then that under constant animal-to-animal aggression the violence escalated until the first fatality occurred in February of 1991. 21-year-old marine biology student Keltie Byrne had fallen into the orca enclosure and drowned after being held underwater and dragged around the pool by the three whales, even after other trainers attempted to halt the three through recall commands and throw Byrne life rings. Less than a year later, Tilikum was moved to SeaWorld Orlando. Sealand of the Pacific closed down not long afterward.
SeaWorld Orlando, believing the change to a bigger area and more resources to be helpful, thought Tilly’s aggressive tendencies would subside until they all but disappeared. Unfortunately, the violent traits that Tilikum acquired were already developed and in full swing by the time he had arrived. For the first seven years though, it seemed that SeaWorld was correct in its assumptions. Tilly was performing well and appeared to have no issues. It seemed Byrne’s death had been a terrible fluke. Until 1999 when 27-year-old Daniel P. Dukes snuck into the enclosure at night and got into Tilly’s tank. He was found dead the next day, drowned on the orca’s back. Dukes was also found with large marks and contusions on his body from the killer whale.
It was in 2010 though that Tilly claimed his last victim in 40-year-old trainer Dawn Brancheau. Brancheau’s death made news across the country, opening up discussion on how badly animals can be impacted by living in captivity, especially once it became public knowledge that she died of not only drowning but also blunt force trauma. Three years later, Blackfish premiered and gave a voice to all these concerns. Director Cowperthwaite delves into the issues with catching wild animals and keeping them in small tanks away from their families and from their natural habitats. Not only was it found that aggression could be linked to animals within close proximity but physically, Tilly had changed too. Cowperthwaite discovered that Tilikum’s fluke which curled under toward his body, was unnatural and that curled flukes and fins only affected whales held in captivity. It showed that the whale in question was unhealthy, this most likely due to the limited space they had in order to swim around as well as their diets which also had no diversification.
On top of this, the ecosystems these killer whales are taken from are losing essential parts of their producer-consumer systems, especially because they are the top consumer and keep populations of other animals under control. A lack of this top consumer means growing numbers for all animals below it which impacts the consumers and/or producers that they eat in order to survive. Taking anything away from its natural habitat will obviously impact more than just the animal or plant one is removing. It also affects all others in that same environment that coexist with them. Taking fish from the ocean for human consumption and entertainment is an issue that has been accumulating for decades (even going back to the 1800s), especially when talking about consumption and how overfishing has already lead to the loss of over 80% of predatory fish.
Blackfish at its time of release discussed how keeping animals in captivity is a risk not only to the animal but also to humans who interact with them. Over time though, the film has become a message on how we are destroying all marine life through our inabilities to manage our fishing tendencies and the unethical ways in which we do so. Blackfish exposes the horrors that silently occur behind closed doors of these large marine life facilities and forces everyone to ask themselves if they are comfortable knowing this is happening all over the world. Because if one person justifies it as being “just one whale”, what happens when 8 billion people do the same?